Elastic CI Stack for AWS vs GitLab Runner
Elastic CI Stack for AWS suits Buildkite customers on AWS that want an autoscaling agent fleet in their own VPC with a vendor-maintained template. GitLab Runner suits teams on GitLab CI/CD that want to run jobs on their own machines, clusters or autoscaled cloud instances. Elastic CI Stack for AWS is an open-source project you run yourself for Buildkite; GitLab Runner is an open-source project you run yourself for GitLab CI.
Key differences between Elastic CI Stack for AWS and GitLab Runner
- CI systems: Only Elastic CI Stack for AWS documents Buildkite. Only GitLab Runner documents GitLab CI.
- Operating systems: Only GitLab Runner documents macOS.
- Isolation: Elastic CI Stack for AWS: EC2 instance. GitLab Runner: Depends on executor.
What they have in common
- Both are open-source projects you run yourself.
- Both document Linux and Windows runners.
- Both document arm64 runners.
- Both are open source.
- Both can be self-hosted.
Elastic CI Stack for AWS vs GitLab Runner at a glance
| Attribute | Elastic CI Stack for AWS | GitLab Runner |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | CloudFormation template (with a Terraform option) that runs an autoscaling group of Buildkite agents on EC2 in your own AWS account. | The open-source agent that runs GitLab CI/CD jobs, with executors for Docker, Kubernetes, shell and autoscaled cloud instances. |
| Type | Open-source project | Open-source project |
| CI systems | Buildkite | GitLab CI |
| Operating systems | Linux, Windows | Linux, macOS, Windows |
| Architectures | x64, arm64 | x64, arm64 |
| Isolation | Agents run on EC2 instances in an Auto Scaling group inside your VPC; instances are reused between jobs by default, and a template parameter can terminate the instance after each job | Depends on the executor: Docker and Kubernetes run jobs in containers, the Docker Autoscaler and Instance executors create cloud instances through fleeting plugins, and the Shell and SSH executors run on the host without a clean build environment |
| Fresh environment per job | Not documented | Not documented |
| Hardware | EC2 instance types set with the InstanceTypes parameter (default t3.large); local NVMe instance storage can be enabled on Linux | Not documented |
| Performance (vendor claim) | Not documented | Not documented |
| Runner sizes | Not documented | Not documented |
| Caching | Git mirrors can be enabled as an agent experiment, and on Linux the builds directory can be placed on local NVMe instance storage. | The docs describe a distributed cache that uses an object storage server (the example uses S3) to share the cache between Docker hosts, and a Docker registry mirror for autoscaled hosts. |
| Docker layer caching | Not documented | Not documented |
| GPU | Not documented | GPU use is documented for the Shell, Docker (gpus option with the NVIDIA Container Toolkit), Kubernetes and Docker Machine executors. |
| Concurrency | Template defaults are MinSize 0 and MaxSize 10 instances with one agent per instance; all three are configurable | Set by the concurrent setting in config.toml; for autoscaling the docs set it to max_instances multiplied by capacity_per_instance |
| Static IPs | Not documented | Not documented |
| SSH into running jobs | Yes | Not documented |
| Pricing | Free and open source; you pay for the infrastructure it runs on. Buildkite notes that the AWS services are pay-as-you-go and that Buildkite services are billed according to your plan. | Free and open source; you pay for the infrastructure it runs on. The docs list it for the Free, Premium and Ultimate tiers. |
| Free tier | Not documented | Not documented |
| Open source | Yes (MIT) | Yes (MIT) |
| Self-host / your cloud | Yes / Yes | Yes / Yes |
| Compliance | Not documented | Not documented |
| Regions | All AWS Regions except China and US GovCloud | Not documented |
| Company headquarters | Melbourne, Victoria, Australia | Not documented |
| Good fit for | Buildkite customers on AWS that want an autoscaling agent fleet in their own VPC with a vendor-maintained template | Teams on GitLab CI/CD that want to run jobs on their own machines, clusters or autoscaled cloud instances |
Verified November 22, 2026 from each provider’s documentation. Performance figures are vendor claims, not our measurements.
Which should you choose?
Reasons to choose Elastic CI Stack for AWS
- You use Buildkite and want agents inside your own AWS account and VPC
- You want a template maintained by Buildkite, with prebuilt Linux and Windows AMIs
- You want the fleet to scale with build activity and down to a minimum of zero instances
- You need Linux on x86 and Arm as well as Windows Server agents
Reasons to choose GitLab Runner
- You use GitLab CI/CD and want to run jobs on infrastructure you control
- You want a choice of executors, from containers on Docker or Kubernetes to full cloud instances
- You want autoscaling on AWS, Google Cloud or Azure with plugins that GitLab maintains
- You need runners on Linux, macOS and Windows from the same project
Trade-offs to check first
- Elastic CI Stack for AWS: The README states that the repository has not been reviewed by security researchers
- Elastic CI Stack for AWS: Builds can reach the EC2 metadata server and act with the IAM permissions of the instance
- GitLab Runner: The Docker Machine executor is deprecated and scheduled for removal in GitLab 20.0
- GitLab Runner: SSH, Shell, Parallels, VirtualBox, Custom and Docker Machine executors receive critical security updates only, with no new features planned
Run your slowest workflow on both before deciding. See the full Elastic CI Stack for AWS profile and GitLab Runner profile, or the complete comparison.
More comparisons
Frequently asked questions
Is Elastic CI Stack for AWS or GitLab Runner better?
What is the difference between Elastic CI Stack for AWS and GitLab Runner?
Which is open source, Elastic CI Stack for AWS or GitLab Runner?
How do Elastic CI Stack for AWS and GitLab Runner isolate jobs?
How does Elastic CI Stack for AWS pricing compare with GitLab Runner?
Do Elastic CI Stack for AWS and GitLab Runner offer GPU runners?
Where do Elastic CI Stack for AWS and GitLab Runner runners run?
Sources
- github.com/buildkite/elastic-ci-stack-for-aws
- github.com/buildkite/elastic-ci-stack-for-aws/releases
- github.com/buildkite/elastic-ci-stack-for-aws/blob/main/Licence.md
- github.com/buildkite/elastic-ci-stack-for-aws/blob/main/templates/aws-stack.yml
- docs.gitlab.com/runner/
- docs.gitlab.com/runner/executors/
- docs.gitlab.com/runner/executors/docker_autoscaler/
- docs.gitlab.com/runner/executors/instance/
Check before you rely on it. Products change quickly, and this page reflects public documentation as of November 22, 2026. Confirm anything that matters in the provider’s own documentation.
Cite this page
CI Runners. (2026). Elastic CI Stack for AWS vs GitLab Runner. cirunners.org. Last reviewed November 22, 2026. https://cirunners.org/compare/buildkite-elastic-ci-stack-vs-gitlab-runner/